Legal Speaks Home Debbie Hines Bio Blog TV Clips Practice Areas Res Ipsa Loquitur Links Contact
Blog Home

Posts Tagged ‘impeachment’

White House Gangsta in Chief Needs to Leave

Wednesday, January 23rd, 2019

Donald Trump, Public Domain

The federal government shutdown has now gone into two missing paychecks for workers without any resolution. It started as Trump’s demand that Mexico would pay for the wall. Then it advanced to American taxpayers would need to pay for the wall. Mexico likely laughed at the suggestion of their paying for it. And now it has snowballed into a hostage take over situation of over 800,000 federal government workers plus contract workers being furloughed until presumably American taxpayers pay for the wall. Trump has placed America at risk in food safety, air safety, health safety, economics, intelligence and basic human rights.

While the focus at times has been on federal government workers in the DC, Maryland and Virginia area, federal employees work in all 50 states plus the District of Columbia. Large numbers of workers are located in Montana, Wyoming, New Mexico, South Dakota, West Virginian and Iowa –Trump Red states. There are government contractors who are not government employees who will never receive back pay.

There is so much at stake with the government shutdown. The lives and well being of 800,000 employees and their families are at stake. Most families are merely one paycheck away from homelessness. Rents and mortgages due are not being paid by many workers. Food lines and food pantries are now feeding government workers and supplying food for their families. The Department of Agriculture may need to forego food stamps distribution in February and SNAP benefits to 40 million Americans. The SNAP program began in 1964. There has never been a lapse in providing food services since the program began. The Food and Drug Administration is lacking the ability to keep our food supply safe, in terms of inspection.

The FBI cannot effectively work. The FBI Agents Association warned Tuesday that the ongoing government shutdown is not only hurting individual FBI employees and their families, but hampering key operations. This means that gangs such as MS-13 and other criminal enterprises will not receive appropriate investigation, indictments and court documents resulting in a likely increase in crime.

The TSA workers who make on average $30,000 must continue to do their jobs without pay. Many TSA workers have already called in sick causing check points at various airports, including Baltimore Washington airport to close checkpoints. Air traffic controllers are now beginning to call in sick. At some point, our air traffic safety will result in a tragedy of huge proportions.

Presently, there is no end in sight. Donald Trump ran at least four companies into bankruptcy. He appears on track to make America his fifth bankruptcy. If the U.S. were a private company, like Trump is running it, he would have already been removed. Papa John’s Pizza removed its CEO and founder under less severe issues than those being displayed by Trump.

One thing is for sure. Trump has a chokehold on America. A CBS News poll found that 71 percent of Americans do not believe the government should be shutdown over Trump’s demands for a border wall payment. Unless our lawmakers find a way around his insanity, our country will be crippled even further. And Trump and Putin will be laughing all the whole time. It’s time to begin impeachment. We cannot wait much longer—if America is to survive. As Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib stated, “impeach the mother fucker”.

Washington, DC based Debbie Hines is an attorney and former prosecutor.

2018- A Year of Sex, Lies, Guns and Trump

Tuesday, January 1st, 2019

Donald Trump, Public Domain

Every new year, we look back towards the past year to see the good, bad and ugly. If 2018 can be boiled down to a theme—it would be sex, lies, guns and Trump. Trump fits into all three categories.

Guns were rampant again this year with no end in sight in terms of gun control. On February 26, 2018, in Parkland, Florida, one of the safest towns in the U.S. , a school gun shooting occurred and 17 persons died including teachers and students. This time may have been different than previous gun shootings in that it galvanized students to hold the March for Our Lives on March 25, 2018. It once again raised the issue of gun control. Like in so many times and years before, no meaningful gun legislation occurred.

 

On June 29, five journalists were shot and killed at the Annapolis Gazette in Annapolis, MD. Throughout the Trump administration, Donald Trump has shouted chants that the media is the enemy of the state. Our constitution’s first amendment is freedom of the press. Yet, the person sitting in the White House holding the office of President continues to attack the press as an enemy. While the shooting and death of 5 journalists is not directly attributable to Trump, the constant attacks on the media with chants of fake news using the term “enemy”, have no place in the U.S. Following the deaths of the journalists, the Trump administration had to be convinced that a lowering of the U.S. flag in mourning was appropriate.

October 28, 11 persons were killed while holding religious services in a Pittsburg synagogue. Following Trump’s 2017 response to the Charlottesville, VA killing of Heather Heyer during a neo-Nazi march, many persons in Pittsburgh had no desire to see Trump visit there. In 2017, Trump all but defended the neo-Nazi’s hatred of Jews  stating there were fault on both sides of the aisle. As a former prosecutor, I understand that violence and hatred have no place in this country. Apparently, Donald Trump doesn’t fully understand the ramifications of spewing hatred with words and acts. Both have consequences.

Sex played an important part in 2018. From Supreme Court justice Brett Kavanaugh, CBS executive Les Moonves, Bill Cosby to Donald Trump, sexual harassment, sex crimes and paybacks continued to play a huge part in 2018. CBS executive Les Moonves lost not only his job but a $120 million severance pay, after an independent investigation revealed a decades long history of sexual harassment against women employees. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh fared better than Moonves. Professor Christine Blasey Ford testified publicly accusing Brett Kavanaugh of attempted rape in high school, with “100%” certainty. Many Republican lawmakers still voted to confirm Kavanaugh to a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court. It just goes to show how little has changed since the Clarence Thomas hearing and Anita Hill’s testimony.

In a different outcome, on September 26, Bill Cosby, once considered America’s TV dad, received a sentence of 3-10 years in prison for sexual assaults committed against Andrea Constand which occurred 14 years earlier. In April, Cosby was convicted of three counts of aggravated sexual assault and classified a “sexually violent predator” requiring lifetime registration.

From accounts from the Mueller investigation, Donald Trump was implicated in ordering and directing the payment of hush money and other ways to silence his sexual escapades with several women, according to alleged testimony by his fixer, attorney Michael Cohen and others. It is suspected that if such behavior had been known, it may have derailed his presidential outcome. We will never know.

According to the Washington Post as reported by Fact Checker’s database, Trump had an unprecedented year of deception averaging 15 false claims a day in 2018. This triples the amount from the year before, according to Fact Checker. This would account for a November Quinnipiac poll which found that 58% of voters saying Trump wasn’t honest. For obvious reasons, there is not enough room to discuss his voluminous false claims in 2018.
Aside from false claims, Trump continues to side with Russian President Putin at every opportunity. In 2018, he sided with Putin saying there was no 2016 Russian interference in our election—going against the report of our U.S. intelligence community. At every turn, Trump has tried to derail the Mueller investigation—changing Attorney Generals. His most dreaded fear of impeachment may occur in 2019.

The latest Trump debacle is the government shutdown. Trump refused to sign legislation on December 22 that would allow the government to remain open and running. Instead he insisted on $5 billion for a wall between the U.S. and Mexico. As of January 1, 2019, the federal government workers and contract workers remain hostage to a wall without pay—that Mexico was supposed to pay for.

2019 brings the hope of some stability in the government with the oversight of the Democrats taking control of the House.

Washington, DC based Debbie Hines is a lawyer and former Baltimore prosecutor.

Trump and Implications of Cohen and Manafort Convictions

Wednesday, August 29th, 2018

Donald Trump, Public Domain

Robert Mueller and his team of special prosecutors had a great week with the convictions of Paul Manafort and Michael Cohen.  As soon as the jury went out to deliberate, Manafort and his lawyers attempted to reach a deal for Manafort. Presently, they were unsucessful. The second trial with Manafort begins September 24, 2018.  And while neither man has been sentenced, there are still many legal implications for Trump with his lawyer of over 12 years and his campaign chairman being convicted.  While the convictions do not involve the Russian collusion or meddling in our election, they are a tipping point to what lies ahead for Donald Trump.

Last week, I discussed the Trump, Cohen and Manafort convictions on CGTN-America TV. Watch here:

 

 

Time to Begin the Process to Pull the Plug on Trump

Wednesday, May 17th, 2017
Donald Trump, Public Domain

Donald Trump, Public Domain

 

 

The latest news surrounding Donald Trump has some persons calling for impeachment, removal or resignation of Trump as president.  In a memo made by then FBI Director James Comey, Trump allegedly asked Comey if he would end the investigation of former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn. It was allegedly made the day after Flynn resigned. Comey declined.  The issue is whether this request, if proven to be true, should be considered obstruction of justice and if so, what remedies exist.

 

Obstruction of justice is a federal statute that makes it unlawful to corruptly obstruct, influence or impede an official proceeding.  There are several key elements to proving the crime.  First, there must be an intent on the part of the person to specifically obstruct, influence or impede. The party must be aware that an investigation or proceeding exists. And the action must be one that attempts to obstruct, influence or impede.  In looking at the totality of the circumstances surrounding what is being alleged by former FBI Director James Comey, it appears that all criteria have been met.

 

The memo of Comey does not stand alone in a vacuum. Putting together the pieces of the puzzle is an easy one. First, there was a dinner meeting at the White House where Comey asserts that Trump allegedly asked him to pledge his loyalty to the President. According to Comey, he declined to pledge his allegiance to Trump.  Now there’s the Comey memo asserting that Trump asked Comey to drop the investigation against Michael Flynn.  Comey continued with the investigation. And of course, Comey was fired by Trump.  If a sitting president, having the power to end one’s career or position makes the request that Trump allegedly made, it would indicate that all criteria of the federal obstruction of justice statute have been met.  But that doesn’t end the matter.

 

Donald Trump is the sitting president of the U.S. with certain protections against criminal prosecution.  The Supreme Court has not ruled whether a sitting president can be charged with a federal crime in lieu of impeachment.  If any other politician had done the alleged actions, he or she would likely be facing a criminal indictment by a Grand Jury shortly.  But the President of the United States’ removal is based on impeachment or use of the 25th amendment under the Constitution.

 

Impeachment proceedings, as were done in the case of former President Bill Clinton, must be started with a majority of the House and then a full trial in the Senate with 2/3 members of the Senate in support.  With the GOP controlled House and Senate, impeachment is an option but a political one. And unfortunately, it’s still too soon to know if enough Republican law makers will pull the plug on their President. My mother used to have a saying that if you make your bed hard, you must lay in it. And Republicans may still prefer to lay in their bed with Trump, instead of formal impeachment charges.

 

The other method to oust a sitting president is found in Section 4 of the 25th amendment of the U. S. Constitution which states that a president may be removed if he or she is found unable to serve or to discharge one’s duties.  This option has never been used and likely won’t be used in Trump’s case—under our present circumstances. And it requires a 2/3 majority in the House and Senate to permanently remove a president.

 

We have likely only hit the tip of the iceberg here. And that’s where an independent commission or special prosecutor is needed.  At this point with Trump potentially asking officials to end investigations, we need a special prosecutor who can dig deep without fear of reprisal, recusal or removal.

 

And speaking of removal, the last method might be the president’s resignation. That would require many Republican leaders to convince Trump that he can’t continue to serve. Whichever method is considered, it won’t be an easy or quick fix.  Speaker Paul Ryan states he still has “confidence” in Trump, despite the newest allegations.  I suspect some Republicans are likely going through the five stages of grieving which are denial, anger, depression, bargaining and acceptance.

 

One thing is for sure. More Republicans will be getting out of bed with Trump and saying enough is enough.

Debbie Hines appears on WUSA 9 with Bruce Johnson on May 17, 2017 to discuss Trump, Comey and special prosecutor:

http://www.wusa9.com/opinion/editorials/off-script/-offscripton9-can-trump-be-impeached-over-comey-memo-/440628580 

Washington, DC based Debbie Hines is a trial lawyer, legal analyst and former Baltimore prosecutor.